不同生物炭协同蚯蚓钝化工业污泥中重金属及环境风险研究

Research on the passivation of heavy metals in industrial sludge and environmental risks using multi-type biochar in collaboration with earthworms

  • 摘要: 为探讨不同类型生物炭协同蚯蚓堆肥对工业污泥重金属(Cu、Zn、Pb、Ni)生物有效性和安全风险的影响,分别将3种生物炭(稻壳炭、竹炭、秸秆炭)和蚯蚓添加到工业污泥中堆肥,分析不同类型生物炭协同蚯蚓堆肥对污泥理化性质和重金属总量、有效态、形态和环境风险的影响。结果表明:蚯蚓堆肥相较于污泥单独堆肥,能降低污泥pH、OM,升高TN、TP、EC;3种生物炭与蚯蚓协同进一步降低污泥pH、OM,增加TN、TP、EC,其中4%竹炭的添加效果最佳。与污泥堆肥和蚯蚓堆肥相比,生物炭协同蚯蚓堆肥显著降低重金属含量和生物有效性,4%稻壳炭协同蚯蚓堆肥对Ni、Cu、Zn的去除效果较好,总量较对照组分别下降31.71%、13.51%、25.89%(P<0.05),有效态分别下降42.80%、23.27%、11.06%(P<0.05)。形态分析表明:生物炭协同蚯蚓堆肥将Cu向有机结合态和残渣态转化,Pb、Ni、Zn向铁锰氧化物结合态和残渣态转化,其中4%竹炭协同蚯蚓堆肥时转化率最高,钝化效果较好。3种生物炭协同蚯蚓处理污泥潜在生态风险均属于低风险:稻壳炭协同蚯蚓处理风险最低(RI为95.9),秸秆炭协同蚯蚓处理风险相对较高(RI为97.04)。健康风险评价发现处理组中非致癌物质通过经口摄入、皮肤接触和呼吸摄入途径对成人和儿童造成的非致癌总风险HI均小于1,处于人体可接受水平,秸秆炭协同蚯蚓处理总风险最小(HI为0.092)。综上,生物炭协同蚯蚓堆肥为降低污泥中的重金属含量及生态风险提供了有效策略,竹炭在改善理化性质和钝化重金属方面较好,稻壳炭在去除重金属总量和安全性方面优于竹炭、秸秆炭,而秸秆炭则在整体风险控制中表现良好,三者均展现出良好的应用潜力。

     

    Abstract: To investigate the effects of different types of biochar co-composting with earthworms on the bioavailability and safety risks of heavy metals (Cu, Zn, Pb, Ni) in industrial sludge, three types of biochar (rice husk charcoal, bamboo charcoal, straw charcoal) and earthworms were added to industrial sludge for composting. The effects of different types of biochar co-composting with earthworms on the physical and chemical properties of sludge, as well as the total amount, availability, morphology, and environmental risks of heavy metals were analyzed. The results showed that compared to composting sludge alone, vermicomposting can lower the pH and OM, and increase TN, TP and EC. Three types of biochar collaborated with earthworms to further reduce the pH of sludge OM, and increase TN, TP, EC. The addition of 4% bamboo charcoal had the best effect. Compared with sludge compost and earthworm compost, biochar combined with earthworm compost significantly reduced heavy metal content and bioavailability. 4% rice husk charcoal combined with earthworm compost had better removal effects on Ni, Cu and Zn, with a total reduction of 31.71%, 13.51% and 25.89% (P<0.05) compared to the control group (T0), and an effective state reduction of 42.80%, 23.27% and 11.06% (P<0.05), respectively. Morphological analysis showed that biochar combined with earthworm compost transformed Cu into organic bound and residual states, while Pb, Ni and Zn transformed into iron manganese oxide bound and residual states. Among them, 4% bamboo charcoal combined with earthworm compost had the highest conversion rate and better passivation effect. The potential ecological risks of three types of biochar combined with earthworms for sludge treatment were all low: rice husk charcoal combined with earthworms had the lowest risk (RI of 95.9), while straw charcoal combined with earthworms had a relatively higher risk (RI = 97.04). The health risk assessment found that the total non-carcinogenic risk (HI) of non-carcinogenic substances to adults and children through oral intake, skin contact, and respiratory intake in the treatment group was less than 1, which was at an acceptable level for the human body. The total risk of straw charcoal combined with earthworms was the lowest (HI = 0.092). In summary, the combination of biochar and earthworm composting provides an effective strategy for reducing heavy metal content and ecological risks in sludge. Bamboo charcoal is better at improving physical and chemical properties and passivating heavy metals, while rice husk charcoal is superior to bamboo charcoal and straw charcoal in terms of total heavy metal removal and safety. Straw charcoal performs well in overall risk control. All three have demonstrated good application potential.

     

/

返回文章
返回