固定污染源烟气可凝结颗粒物测试方法对比研究

Comparative study of test methods for condensable particulate matter in flue gas from stationary sources

  • 摘要: 随着固定污染源超低排放技术的广泛应用,可凝结颗粒物(CPM)在总颗粒物排放中的占比显著上升,已成为制约深度减排的关键因素,但目前尚缺乏统一的标准测量方法。通过对典型工业源开展现场实测与分析,评估稀释间接法、均相控制冷凝法及非均相控制冷凝法这三种方法测量结果的差异。结果表明:不同方法测得的CPM质量浓度存在显著差异,呈现非均相控制冷凝法>均相控制冷凝法>稀释间接法的规律。这是因为传统冷凝法因水蒸气相变过程促使NH3、SO2和HCl等可溶性气体在冷凝液中二次溶解,造成CPM浓度的高估。相比之下,稀释间接法通过模拟烟气在开放环境中的动态稀释-冷凝过程,规避了冲击瓶接触导致的溶解干扰,更真实地反映了CPM的大气环境排放特征。而水溶性离子作为CPM的主要组分,其浓度分布特征与总浓度趋势一致,在燃煤锅炉和水泥窑尾气CPM中分别占比77.6%和55.4%以上。其中燃煤锅炉CPM以\mathrmSO_4^2- (31.2%)、\mathrmNH_4^+ (28.7%)和Cl(17.5%)为主导组分,而水泥窑尾气CPM则以\mathrmNH_4^+ (61.3%)为主要成分。本研究为优化CPM测量方法及准确评估其环境效应提供了实证依据。

     

    Abstract: With the widespread application of ultra-low emission technologies in stationary sources, the proportion of condensable particulate matter (CPM) in total particulate emissions has increased significantly, becoming a critical constraint for further emission reduction. However, a unified standard measurement method is still lacking. This study conducted field measurements and analyses on typical industrial sources to evaluate the differences in measurement results obtained by three methods: the indirect dilution method, the homogeneous controlled condensation method, and the heterogeneous controlled condensation method. The results indicated significant differences in the measured CPM mass concentrations among the methods, following the order of heterogeneous controlled condensation > homogeneous controlled condensation > indirect dilution. This discrepancy was attributed to the fact that traditional condensation methods caused an overestimation of CPM concentrations due to the secondary dissolution of soluble gases (e.g., NH3, SO2, and HCl) into the condensate during the water vapor phase transition. In contrast, the indirect dilution method simulated the dynamic dilution and condensation process of flue gas in an open environment, thereby avoiding dissolution interference caused by contact with impinger liquids and more accurately reflecting the atmospheric emission characteristics of CPM. Water-soluble ions, as the major components of CPM, exhibited concentration trends consistent with total CPM concentrations, accounting for over 77.6% and 55.4% of CPM in coal-fired boiler and cement kiln flue gases, respectively. Specifically, CPM from coal-fired boilers was dominated by \mathrmSO_4^2- (31.2%), \mathrmNH_4^+ (28.7%) and Cl(17.5%), whereas CPM from cement kilns was primarily composed of \mathrmNH_4^+ (61.3%). This study provides a crucial empirical basis for optimizing CPM measurement methods and accurately assessing their environmental effects.

     

/

返回文章
返回